New WWE Wyatt Sicks Members

With the Road to WrestleMania 42 kicking off soon, there could be brand new members set to join the Wyatt Sicks faction on WWE SmackDown.

From obvious additions, to potential returns that could become the perfect new addition to the group — there are some exciting possibilities as to who might link up with the frightening faction.

Here are seven potential new WWE Wyatt Sicks members.

7. Alexa Bliss

While certainly the most obvious choice, there are still some fans that hope to see Alexa Bliss join forces with the Wyatt Sicks.

Although her connection to the group within storyline hasn’t ever been specifically addressed, she obviously has a great amount of history with Bray Wyatt.

With Alexa Bliss and Charlotte Flair’s partnership continuing beyond the length it was originally planned, it may be that if Flair is going her own singles direction heading into WrestleMania 42 — perhaps there is something big awaiting Bliss as well.

Able to tell a very interesting storyline regardless of the specific details, it could be that Bliss seeks to take over the group or more along the lines of the group hoping to take control of Alexa Bliss.

Click the next page button below for more

6. Shayna Baszler

A potential returning WWE star that could join forces with the Wyatt Sicks might be Shayna Baszler.

After being released from WWE in May 2025, Baszler is seemingly still on good terms with the company.

Notably trying her hand at producing backstage in NXT during her non-compete period in WWE, Baszler even appeared on-screen as a part of a storyline for NXT Homecoming.

With her Queen of Spades character from NXT not having a solid opportunity to shine on the main roster, there could be an amazing opportunity to re-launch Baszler with the Wyatt Sicks.

Click the next page button below for more

5. Tatum Paxley

Recently suffering a big betrayal at the hands of The Culling who had claimed to be her family, Tatum Paxley could soon seek out a new family in the Wyatt Sicks.

Becoming an amazing tag team partner for Nikki Cross, the duo could end up becoming major contenders for the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship in 2026.

Bringing her own dark yet sympathetic character to the group, Paxley would also become a conduit for future departures from the ‘classic characters’ referenced in the Firefly Funhouse segments.

Branching out to include new characters, there could become even more opportunities for off-shoots from the Wyatt Sicks to make their presence felt across brands — including AAA and TNA Wrestling.

Click the next page button below for more

4. Brooks Jensen

Speaking of The Culling, another star that was cast aside by his former family was Brooks Jensen.

Able to bring a new aspect of potentially sadistic tendencies to The Wyatt Sicks, Jensen could be positioned as a project that Uncle Howdy vowed to take on but that may backfire in the end.

Potentially too wild to be tamed to truly join the family and work towards a collective goal, the addition of Brooks Jensen to the group would be less of a new character and more of a brand new long-term storyline for the squad.

Slowly revealing himself over time to be much more evil than anyone expected, Brooks Jensen could end up seeing a total character reinvention on the main roster.

Click the next page button below for more

3. Candice LeRae

Setting the stage for a brand new feud for the group, there could be a surprise twist to kick off the rivalry.

While #DIY (Tommaso Ciampa & Johnny Gargano) have seen plenty of ups and downs with one another, it could be an intriguing twist to see their alliance face a different kind of betrayal.

Potentially leading them to slaughter herself, Candice LeRae could be responsible for delivering the pair directly into the hands of the Wyatt Sicks’ dastardly intentions.

Serving as a captivating tag team partner for Nikki Cross, there could be some incredible bouts moving forward in the women’s tag team division.

Click the next page button below for more

2. Shiloh Hill

One potential recruit for the Wyatt Sicks from NXT might be LFG Season Two winner from Team Undertaker, Shiloh Hill.

Amassing a fan following on social media by documenting creepy purchases in shady corners of the internet, Hill could fit right in with the Sicks.

Certainly already showcasing his spooky aura on NXT, it could be that Shiloh Hill was a natural fit for the group if he were called up to the main roster.

Making for an easy segue into the main roster, it could be that Shiloh Hill is headed for SmackDown sooner rather than later.

Click the next page button below for more

1. Charlie Dempsey

Ahead of the WWE Hall of Fame induction of Stephanie McMahon, perhaps there could be a throwback to one of the vintage storylines that launched her on-screen character into WWE legend status.

After The Undertaker and his Ministry of Darkness kidnapped Stephanie McMahon in 1999, she would eventually be rescued by the unlikely hero of Stone Cold Steve Austin.

With the ability for Dempsey to be abducted by the Wyatt Sicks, he could appear on the main roster as a shell of his former personality.

While some babyface emissary of William Regal could work to extract Dempsey from the Sicks’ control, the fun throwback storyline wouldn’t hurt the young star in the long run since he was brainwashed after all, so any catatonic appearances could be easily forgiven.

To make sure you stay up to date with all the biggest wrestling and WrestleTalk news, follow us on Threads by clicking this link!