New WWE Judgment Day Members

With Dirty Dominik Mysterio set to miss some time due to a shoulder injury, the Judgment Day could be on the hunt for new members.

Depending on which member of the current group looks to recruit could yield very different results as there are some intriguing options from around WWE.

Here are six potential new WWE Judgment Day members.

6. Giulia

Joining up with a Roxanne Perez led Judgment Day, the new women’s United States Champion could find herself aligned with the group.

Not necessarily simply functioning on one brand, the Judgment Day could end up expanding their reach from WWE Raw and AAA into SmackDown as well.

Resuming their initial heel partnership from when the duo were called up from NXT to the main roster, Kiana James could come along as well to provide a valuable managerial service.

Rebranding the Judgment Day as a female-led, next generation brand of violence in WWE across both Raw and SmackDown could be a lot of fun.

Click the next page button below for more

5. Charlie Dempsey

In the event there was more of a Finn Balor takeover in the Judgment Day, perhaps the veteran would seek to add some more technical weight to the group.

Bringing Charlie Dempsey from NXT could be not only a fun addition to the group, it could also be a move towards establishing a more serious Judgment Day in the potential ,absence of Dominik Mysterio.

With Dempsey joining forces with Harlem Lewis in competition in Japan in late 2025, he was last seen competing in the ring at TNA Wrestling Final Resolution in early December where he lost a bout to Mike Santana.

Seemingly on the verge of launching on the main roster given his recent absence, it may be that Dempsey ends up joining a brand new Balor led iteration of the Judgment Day.

Click the next page button below for more

4. Lexis King

With the prospect that the Judgment Day’s current endearing manipulator Dirty Dominik Mysterio may be out of action due to injury, perhaps the group could use a new infusion of energy.

NXT star Lexis King could find himself on the main roster as a storyline where he is essentially attempting to try-out for the Judgment Day in Dirty Dom’s absence.

Capturing the same lovable dirtbag vibe, King could end up catching either the intrigue or ire of main roster fans — either way, providing a solid segue to the main roster.

While the partnership wouldn’t need to be permanent as in the end, King could fail to make the Judgment Day cut, it would still be an entertaining and memorable path to get there.

Click the next page button below for more

3. Santos Escobar

One potential new member for the Judgment Day hasn’t been seen in quite some time is Santos Escobar.

While it was reported that Escobar would be returning as a solo act to WWE, the in-ring veteran has yet to make his return to TV.

Potentially appearing as a brand new character, Santos Escobar could still join forces with the Judgment Day and particularly in light of their crossover appeal in AAA.

Boasting a career that features championship experience in AAA (and before that, CMLL) prior to NXT and eventually the main roster, Escobar could be poised for a brand new iteration to take off across brands.

Click the next page button below for more

2. Brooks Jensen

After having been unceremoniously booted out of The Culling, Brooks Jensen would go on to participate in the NXT invasion in TNA Wrestling.

With an impressive stature and the ability to really re-invent in any number of different characters, Jensen could be the ideal muscle to join the group as the Judgment Day may look to enter a new era.

Able to support a female-led Judgment Day, Jensen could also find himself faced with an old friend turned foe in another viable call-up from NXT to join the squad in Josh Briggs.

Reuniting the duo under the banner of the Judgment Day faction, the history from NXT between the pair could be largely ignored as they enter into a new, dark partnership.

Click the next page button below for more

1. Dion Lennox

Looking to reform the Judgment Day, perhaps Liv Morgan would choose to align herself with a brand new group of young and vicious talent.

Another standout from NXT that could join the Judgment Day and change the group might be DarkState’s Dion Lennox.

Emerging as the main character from his current DarkState stable on NXT, it could be that Lennox becomes a new member of Judgment Day but keeps his NXT affiliation.

Able to lead a surprise attack in the future that features DarkState (Osiris Griffin, Cutler James & Saquon Shugars), the entire group could land on the main roster for a storyline.

To make sure you stay up to date with all the biggest wrestling and WrestleTalk news, follow us on Threads by clicking this link!