WWE Stars To Join New Finn Balor Faction Against Judgment Day

On the March 9 edition of WWE Monday Night Raw, The Judgment Day turned on Finn Balor in a four-on-one assault.

Since then, Balor was able to get a measure of revenge by reintroducing his “Demon” persona to defeat Dominik Mysterio in a Street Fight at WWE WrestleMania 42 Night Two.

Now with Mysterio attacking him after his recent win over JD McDonagh, Balor may need some backup to counteract Judgment Day moving forward.

Here are six WWE stars to potentially join a new Finn Balor faction against Judgment Day.

6. Stephanie Vaquer

At WrestleMania 42 Night One, Liv Morgan defeated Stephanie Vaquer to win the WWE Women’s World Championship.

This win came as a result of some interference from The Judgment Day’s Raquel Rodriguez and Roxanne Perez.

After losing the title, Vaquer has let it be known that she still has her sights set on regaining the gold that she just lost.

To help her pursuit to regain the WWE Women’s World Championship, Vaquer could align herself with Balor to take down The Judgment Day and go on to get revenge on Morgan.

5. Tama Tonga

Finn Balor has plenty of history with several names on the WWE roster from his time with the company and from his stint with New Japan Pro Wrestling.

Being the founder and leader of The Bullet Club stable, Balor started the faction alongside Karl Anderson, Bad Luck Fale and Tama Tonga.

Since signing with WWE in 2024, Tonga has been aligned with Solo Sikoa in the New Bloodline and The MFTs. However, the former NJPW star has been going through issues with Sikoa as of late.

Tama going on to align himself with his former Bullet Club stablemate in Balor would make a ton of sense and could see the two men destroying The Judgment Day together.

4. Lyra Valkyria

As a pioneer from the Irish pro wrestling scene, Finn Balor has paved the way for various stars to get their start in WWE.

One of those stars happens to be Lyra Valkyria, who signed with WWE in 2020 and got called up to the main roster in 2024.

Valkyria has gone on to become a former NXT Women’s Champion, WWE Women’s Tag Team Champion and the inaugural WWE Women’s Intercontinental Champion.

With everything she has accomplished, Valkyria could be a beneficial ally against the likes of Liv Morgan, Raquel Rodriguez and Roxanne Perez in The Judgment Day.

3. Rey Mysterio

Since 2022, Rey Mysterio has been one of the biggest rivals for The Judgment Day.

The group helped Rey’s son Dominik Mysterio turn heel and betray him before making his life a living hell over the past four years.

The WWE Hall of Famer could become an asset to Finn Balor now that he is engaged in his own feud with the stable.

Balor calling upon Mysterio would make sense with their individual past against The Judgment Day over the years and might be enough to take down the faction once and for all.

2. Damian Priest

Another rival of The Judgment Day who could join forces with Finn Balor is Damian Priest.

In 2025, Priest made the jump from Monday Night Raw to Friday Night SmackDown after closing the book on his rivalry with The Judgment Day.

Since then, Priest has formed a partnership with R-Truth and captured the WWE Tag Team Championships.

Priest joining forces with his former stablemate Balor to finally put an end to The Judgment Day could become a compelling story to tell.

1. Rhea Ripley

Another former Judgment Day member who might be interested in taking the group down once and for all is Rhea Ripley.

At one time, Ripley was considered by many to be the leader or most prominent member of The Judgment Day since the stable’s start.

However, Dominik Mysterio and the rest of the faction turned on Ripley in favor of Liv Morgan at WWE SummerSlam 2024.

Now that they are both out of the faction, Ripley could reunite with Balor to destroy what they created in The Judgment Day before they destroy themselves.

To make sure you stay up to date with all the biggest wrestling and WrestleTalk news, follow us on Threads by clicking this link!