Former TNA Wrestling Stars To Re-Sign With The Company

TNA Wrestling is about to go into one of the most exciting periods in the company’s history.

Starting in January, TNA will be moving to AMC Network airing every Thursday at 9 p.m. Eastern time.

With the company about to enter a new era, it would make sense if a few former TNA Wrestling stars make their way back to the promotion.

Here are six former TNA Wrestling stars to potentially re-sign with the company.

6. Hammerstone

Signing with TNA Wrestling in 2024, it looked Hammerstone was going to be positioned as a new major star for the promotion.

With his impressive look, size and ability in the ring, Hammerstone is someone who could easily be in the main event picture for any company he ever steps in.

However, the former MLW World Heavyweight Champion only spent a year with TNA Wrestling and never really reached the potential he had when he signed.

Despite currently working for Major League Wrestling again, it feels like TNA Wrestling should pursue bringing Hammerstone back into the fold where he could be a bigger player in the company.

Click the next page button below for more

5. Gisele Shaw

Another former TNA Wrestling star who made a lot of waves recently leaving the company is Gisele Shaw.

Becoming a mainstay for the TNA Knockouts division, Shaw became one of the most entertaining characters in the company.

After leaving the promotion in 2024, Shaw has gone on to reestablish herself on the independent scene in places like Maple Leaf Pro.

Gisele Shaw has the charisma that would work with a grand return to make it work and reinsert herself as a key player in the Knockouts division once more.

Click the next page button below for more

4. Karrion Kross & Scarlett

Many fans were shocked by the announcement that Karrion Kross and Scarlett were leaving WWE following their contracts expiring after SummerSlam 2025.

Not to rest on their laurels, Kross and Scarlett did not waste any time returning to the independent scene and making their presence felt in other promotions.

TNA Wrestling’s upcoming premiere on AMC could open the door for Kross and Scarlett to make an unexpected return to the former home.

After leaving in December 2019, Kross and Scarlett could make their return to TNA Wrestling just in time for the historic night they debut on the AMC Network.

Click the next page button below for more

3. Enzo Amore

Back at TNA Slammiversary 2025, Enzo Amore made his debut with the company as a member of the 4TH Rope Wrestling trio that defeated three men from the TNA roster.

This brief appearance saw Amore with weeks of vignettes to hype his eventual arrival in the promotion.

The former WWE Cruiserweight Champion has been a controversial figure in the world of pro wrestling with many fans not knowing how to react to him.

However, considering the attention he always draws, it wouldn’t be the worst idea to see TNA Wrestling sign Enzo Amore and bring him into the company officially.

Click the next page button below for more

2. Trevor Lee (Cameron Grimes)

Back in 2024, Cameron Grimes was released from WWE after a five-year stint with the company.

Since his release, Grimes has returned to his Trevor Lee moniker and hit the ground running back on the independent scene.

Lee is someone who has the experience and in-ring ability to be a boost for any roster he will be on.

With TNA looking to bolster their talent in a major way before premiering on AMC Network, it would make a ton of sense to bring back one of the most underrated in-ring performers in the game today.

Click the next page button below for more

1. The Good Brothers (Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows)

After their initial release from WWE in 2020, The Good Brothers made their way to TNA Wrestling and became one of the faces of the company.

After capturing the TNA World Tag Team Titles three times, Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson would go on to re-sign with WWE and reunited with AJ Styles in The OC.

Now released for a second time in February 2025, The Good Brothers have returned to the indies and other promotions around the world.

Gallows and Anderson would help to improve the TNA tag team division and set up some tantalizing matchups with the top duos, such as The Hardys, The Rascalz and the newly signed The Righteous.

To make sure you stay up to date with all the biggest wrestling and WrestleTalk news, follow us on Threads by clicking this link!