While the WWE group Judgment Day continues to teeter on collapse, perhaps a break-up could make way for a brand new Judgment Day.
Depending on which members end up sticking around the Clubhouse could dictate the direction and accordingly this list has a little bit of everything!
Here are eight WWE stars to join a new version of Judgment Day.
8. Karrion Kross
There is actually a pretty solid path for Karrion Kross to take over the Judgment Day faction moniker – if he is able to slowly manipulate each member of the group to abandon the squad.
Seemingly easily able to influence the likes of Dirty Dominik Mysterio, Kross could easily cause such friction between Mysterio and Liv Morgan that the women’s Tag Team Champions end up bailing on the group first.
Moving on to convincing JD McDonagh and Finn Balor to drop the deadweight faction and go forward to do their own thing – hyping them up about the possibilities – Kross would just be left basically controlling the group.
Then perhaps electing to add new members for his own purposes, Karrion Kross could end up slowly chipping away at the current faction and launching his own brand new Judgment Day with Scarlett.
Click the next page button below for more
7. Ilja Dragunov
If a new iteration of Judgment Day was set to be helmed by Finn Balor – it would make complete sense for the bar to enter be high.
Already familiar with exercising his dark side to perpetuate violence, Ilja Dragunov would be an exceptional addition to immediately launch the new group.
Dragunov could add an additional element of legitimate threat to Judgment Day and lead the way for JD McDonagh to resume his former NXT character which was decidedly less affable than his current presentation.
Able to make a surprise return to WWE, Dragunov would be the perfect unexpected new member for the group for a hostile takeover by Balor to cast out Dirty Dominik Mysterio.
Click the next page button below for more
6. Ron Killings
While R-Truth has been a quasi-member of Judgment Day before – it would be incredible to see Ron Killings take over in a new Judgment Day.
Clearly already adept at navigating the Judgment Day Clubhouse, Killings could install himself as a new leader fairly quickly.
Given his more frightening facade, there could be a very fun set of interactions with Finn Balor, JD McDonagh and especially Dirty Dominik Mysterio.
Although it seems as though Killings is still poised to feud in the near future with John Cena – he could definitely take over Judgment Day at the same time and become the fast leader of the new squad.
Click the next page button below for more
5. Omos
Where in the world is Omos?! After having last been seen in-ring action in WWE at the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal ahead of WrestleMania 40 in April 2024 – the star does not seem to be injured.
Rather he started 2025 with a successful stint in Pro Wrestling NOAH in Japan, capturing the GHC Tag Team Title and holding it until he vacated the title with comment that he had to depart NOAH to return to WWE.
Almost six months later, there still hasn’t been any return of Omos however – he may be the perfect addition to Judgment Day.
Since his long absence could be used to launch a brand new iteration of his character – Omos could join the new group with entirely unknown intentions and leading to a storyline where his affiliations and purpose for joining the group could be revealed over time.
Click the next page button below for more
4. AJ Styles
With AJ Styles already having a rich history with factions – it could make complete sense to see the veteran star as one of the figure heads of a new Judgment Day.
Able to pick up Finn Balor and JD McDonagh, Styles’ new version of Judgment Day could get back to the roots of the group.
With the original iteration being Edge, Rhea Ripley and Damian Priest – perhaps Styles would resurrect the idea of utilizing underutilized talent in the group.
Able to add the likes of Cruz del Toro or even a big name like Shinsuke Nakamura – seeing a stable headed up by the duo of AJ Styles and Finn Balor would be iconic.
Click the next page button below for more
3. Lola Vice
With Lola Vice recently teaming with Stephanie Vaquer, it seems that she could be headed for big things sooner rather than later.
Since the additional threat of Roxanne Perez has already caused stress for Liv Morgan in the Judgment Day – perhaps adding another female member could crank up the drama even further.
Potentially able to join a new Judgment Day as a replacement recruited by Liv Morgan to try and squeeze out Perez – of course the move would backfire.
Giving a launching point for Lola Vice on the main roster and showing a woman be entirely disinterested in Dirty Dominik Mysterio’s dirtbag charms would be a great short-term story on WWE Raw.
Click the next page button below for more
2. Lexis King
Speaking of dirt bags – how has Dirty Dominik Mysterio not caught wind of Lexis King yet?
Seemingly tailor-made to be a sketchy sidekick to the Dirty one, Lexis King could conceivably join a new iteration of Judgment Day that was meant to be crafted in the image of Mysterio.
With their shared pro wrestling lineage, King could always resurrect his hatred of his Dad (Brian Pillman Jr who passed away in 1997) as a character detail within the storyline as to bond with Dom.
In the end, there may not be any way for two dirtbags of this magnitude to co-exist however so a split might be inevitable.
Click the next page button below for more
1. Logan Paul
One partnership that seems entirely likely based on their shared dirtbag status is that between Logan Paul and Dirty Dominik Mysterio.
Logan Paul could easily join Judgment Day by wooing Dirty Dominik Mysterio but it would in reality be more like an acquisition.
Once in the clubhouse, Paul would immediately take over – changing the aesthetics, setting new expectations and generally disenfranchising any remaining members of the group.
Easily serving as an immediate catalyst to the group breaking up, it would be a fun storyline to watch the members of the group slowly defect one by one as their former safe space completely changed.
To make sure you stay up to date with all the biggest wrestling and WrestleTalk news, follow us on Threads by clicking this link!
Comments.
Loading comments…