Skip to content

WWE star to turn babyface soon: Three heels that could change their ways before the end of 2026

Share

WWE logo

The allegiances of the WWE roster are ever-changing, with heels and babyfaces flipping to the other side of the morality coin throughout the year.

2026 has of course been no exception, with this month giving us heel turns from Tiffany Stratton and Cruz Montana on SmackDown and Raw respectively.

Advertisement

When looking at the heel side of the WWE roster, there are several names that could be on the verge of going the other way and turning babyface – with one example potentially set to turn after less than a year as a “bad guy.”

Here are three WWE stars that could potentially turn babyface before the end of 2026:

Randy Orton

Much like John Cena’s heel turn last year, WWE fans have not bought into Randy Orton as a bad guy since the moment he turned on Cody Rhodes on March 13.

Advertisement

No matter what Orton said or did to Rhodes, fans still cheered him more than “The American Nightmare.” Even the introduction of Pat McAfee as Orton’s confidant ahead of WrestleMania 42 didn’t really accomplish WWE’s mission to get “The Viper” true heat, with fans more just upset that WWE had shoehorned a celebrity figure like Pat into a storyline he had no place being involved in.

After two more matches against each other, Orton and Rhodes’ rivalry is no more, and in their last meeting at Crown Jewel – where Orton was once again the overwhelming fan favorite by the way – Rhodes hit his former mentor with a punt kick to seemingly write him off of TV.

We may not even see Orton back before the new year, but whenever he does show back up, expect WWE to scrap the heel character and instead have Orton revelling in the fans’ love once more. There’s just no point forcing a heel run that nobody wants.

Johnny Gargano

Advertisement

Unlike Orton, Johnny Gargano is not someone who needs a babyface turn per se, as he’s actually doing some of his best work as Sami Zayn’s loyal sidekick.

However, Gargano’s loyalty to Zayn is conditional to an extent, he’s expecting to receive the Undisputed WWE Championship match that he is owed; a title shot that Zayn seemingly has no intention of giving him.

Of course Zayn is not telling Gargano that and he’s making an effort to come across like he’s trying to get that match booked. Zayn has claimed to have talked to SmackDown General Manager Nick Aldis, but there’s always an excuse as to why the match hasn’t been made.

Eventually Aldis is going to reveal that Zayn’s supposed conversations about getting Gargano a title shot never actually happened, leading to the Undisputed WWE Champion losing his most loyal “Ride or Die.”

Advertisement

Big Cass

The Big Cass solo star experiment has not quite panned out for WWE thus far, and it’s difficult to see things turning around for the former AEW star anytime soon. That is, if WWE doesn’t make a change to Cass’ booking or overall character direction.

The easiest and most logical change WWE can make is, of course, turning Cass babyface and reuniting him with his former tag team partner Enzo Amore.

Amore is now reportedly under WWE contract once again, but the company’s reported plans are to send the former Cruiserweight Champion to NXT.

Advertisement

If Cass was thriving on his own then this would be understandable, but given his struggles to get over as a heel – and WWE’s overall need for good tag teams right now – they should instead give fans the Enzo and Cass reunion they’ve been wanting.

To make sure you stay up to date with all the biggest wrestling and WrestleTalk news, follow us on Threads by clicking this link!

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Discover more from WrestleTalk

Add WrestleTalk as a preferred source on Google to see more of our reporting.

Follow

Related Stories.